DETOUR - Towards Pre-trial Detention as Ultima Ratio
The use of alternatives to pretrial detention, however, is not without difficulties for both suspects and practitioners. In the countries represented in the project, the availability of alternatives to pretrial detention and their use vary considerably. They may take less invasive forms, such as release on recognizance with some obligations attached such as reporting regularly to the authorities. But they also may take the form of curfew, electronically monitored curfew, other forms of (police) supervision, or drug treatment. A fundamental problem that may arise from the use of alternatives to pretrial detention is the potential for net-widening and there can also be a “hidden agenda” of e.g. punitive or coercive aims, which may go beyond the legitimate goals. Further problems are the possible exclusion of foreigners or homeless persons from such alternatives.
This projects aims at exploring and analyzing pre-trial detention practice, especially different ways of reducing the use of pre-trial detention in seven European jurisdictions. It is, on the one hand, focused on the human rights situation of the suspects who in principle should benefit from the presumption of innocence. On the other hand it addresses the views and needs of the judiciary which also depends on available alternatives as well as on other obstacles they experience with respect to the avoidance of pre trail detention. Increasingly, and this will be another focus, cross-border cases need to be solved within the EU, like for instance with the European Supervision order. The project aims at increasing mutual knowledge about other jurisdictions within the EU. Central to all project activities, although not restricted to them, are judges and prosecutors, because they are the ones who decide also dependent on and influenced by given conditions. The project is about learning from and with each other and to contribute to developments fostering the avoidance of pre-trial detention.
The project was funded by the Justice Programme of the European Commission and supported by the Austrian Ministry of Justice.
Project Partners
- Ernst Moritz Arndt University of Greifswald, Faculty of Law (EMAU), Germany
- The National Institute of Criminalistics and Criminology (NICC), Belgium
- University of Utrecht, Faculty of Law (UU), The Netherlands
- Dublin Institute of Technology (DIT), Ireland
- Law Institute of Lithuania (LIL), Lithuania
- Associations of Schools of social Work in Romania (ASSW), Romania
Project Period
January 2016 - December 2018
Project Management
Publications
First National Reports: Basics on Pre-trial Detention in the partner countries
Second National Reports: Reports on expert interviews in the partner countries